Is the Kylebooker Kamasan B170 Sproat – 100 Pack – Fly Hooks Worth the Money?
For avid fly fishermen, finding high-quality hooks at a reasonable price is essential. The Kylebooker Kamasan B170 Sproat fly hooks come in a 100-pack, promising durability, sharpness, and reliability. But does this product deliver good value for money? Let’s break down its features, performance, and overall cost-effectiveness.
1. Hook Design and Quality
The Kamasan B170 Sproat is a well-known hook pattern among fly tyers. Its sproat bend provides excellent hooking power, while the forged construction ensures strength without adding unnecessary weight. The bronze finish offers corrosion resistance, which is crucial for freshwater and light saltwater use.
One standout feature is the micro barb, which helps secure the fish while still being relatively easy to remove—ideal for catch-and-release fishing. The sharpness of these hooks is impressive right out of the box, reducing the need for additional honing before use.
2. Performance in Different Fishing Conditions
These hooks are versatile, suitable for nymphs, wet flies, and small streamers. Their fine wire construction allows for natural presentation, making them great for trout, grayling, and panfish. However, anglers targeting larger species (like steelhead or bass) might find them slightly lightweight.
In terms of durability, the B170 holds up well against bending or breaking, even when fighting moderately sized fish. The bronze coating resists rust longer than cheaper alternatives, though prolonged saltwater exposure may still require rinsing and drying.
3. Price and Value
The 100-pack format is where the Kylebooker Kamasan B170 shines. Buying in bulk significantly reduces the cost per hook, making it a budget-friendly choice compared to purchasing smaller quantities of premium brands like Tiemco or Daiichi.
For example:
– A 25-pack of Tiemco TMC 3769 (a comparable hook) can cost $8–$12, equating to $0.32–$0.48 per hook.
– The Kylebooker 100-pack typically retails for $20–$25, dropping the cost to just $0.20–$0.25 per hook.
This makes the B170 an excellent option for fly tyers who go through hooks quickly or guides needing reliable backups.
4. Potential Drawbacks
While the value is strong, a few minor issues exist:
– Size consistency: A few users report slight variations in hook size within the batch, though this is rare.
– Not for heavy-duty use: The fine wire isn’t ideal for toothy species (e.g., pike or saltwater gamefish).
5. Verdict: Good Value for Most Fly Anglers
If you primarily fish for trout, panfish, or small stream species, the Kylebooker Kamasan B170 Sproat 100-pack is a cost-effective, high-performing choice. The sharpness, corrosion resistance, and bulk pricing make it a smart buy for both beginners and seasoned fly tyers.
However, if you need heavy-duty saltwater hooks or ultra-premium finishes, investing in Tiemco or Gamakatsu might be better. For the price, though, the B170 delivers exceptional value and is highly recommended for most freshwater applications.
Final Rating: 4.5/5 (Excellent for the price, with minor trade-offs in heavy-duty use).
Would you try these hooks? Share your thoughts in the comments! 🎣